If you're at all in any circle that in any way comes into contact with someone autistic, you've probably seen all that is going around concerning the movie "Music" by Sia. I haven't given it a watch, because I really don't know if I could sit through it, but from the clips I've seen, it's incredibly offensive.
The main argument, which I agree with, is that the movie's main character (played by Maddie Ziegler) is neurotypical and plays a pretty severe caricature of an autistic person.
Within that discussion has been a much more important one, with actual autistics discussing media that portrays autistic and neurodiversity in a respectful way. Most of the depictions in media have grown to be slightly less offensive and slightly more understanding of individual needs and experiences. There are several shows that have done some homework before putting autistic people into a storyline, ones that show respect and understanding to the character and allow for their wishes to be respected.
What is harder to find is a show that portrays what a family goes through with a child on the spectrum, and what it's like for those around them. It seems like the vast majority of depictions of families focus on either the dysfunction it causes or the trials that the diagnosis causes.
Which gets me to the show "everyone" has been discussing recently, claiming it to be a respectful depiction of an autistic child and his family, The A Word. On the surface its another British drama series set in semi-rural England, focusing on a five year old's (Joe) diagnosis and his family through the process.
Joe's family is a blended one, with extended family nearby. He lives with his parents and half sister. Next door his uncle and aunt and somewhere in town his grandfather is never far. At the time of his diagnosis, the family is also going through some family shifts with the aunt and uncle moving in and his father opening a restaurant. All very stressful things.
There's another British show that I hold in high esteem as far as depicting special needs parenting, There She Goes, and The A Word is not in any way similar. I do feel though, that it has a very relevant place in the world.
What There She Goes portrays so beautifully is a poignant view into a family that was straddled with a life long disability in one of their children. It feels real, it feels genuine, and if you've been in those shoes, it cuts close to home.
The A Word deals with another type of very authentic, but significantly different point of view. It's the point of view of parents that simply do not understand their child. Their child is so obviously in need of so many things, but his parents are so hopelessly determined to do it a different way that they both force Joe to suffer as well as their marriage. Their grief and process of dealing with the diagnosis their child has been given is genuine, their love for him endless, but watching from the sidelines all I can feel is pity for the child.
As my husband and I have sat there and watched, we've repeatedly screamed "NO!" at the TV. Watching his parents talk past him, his father attempting to get him to stifle his outbursts, and his mother's constant insistence on not using the word "autism" is a test in patience. But even then, those parents are out there, and I know I've met them.
Which gets me to why I'm here. Last night after watching an episode my husband and I began to discuss what it was that we actually liked about the show. The best I could come up with, was that it was reverse competency porn. Basically watching someone do it wrong, was making me feel like I was doing it right. I'm not sure if its the best description, but it's the best I can muster.
Watching a child that so desperately needs to be loved for who he is, being put through the trials of his parents own journey with the diagnosis, is difficult. It made me think a lot about my own journey, the fears, the disappointments, all of the worries. I had, and have, those. These fears are all fears parents have for their child. No one wants their child to be at a disadvantage because of a diagnosis, but at the cost of their personhood?
What I've learned in the short two years as the parent of an autistic child is this, my kid is brilliant, and so is every child with autism. We are the ones who do not possess the abilities to see it. Neurotypicals are the ones at the disadvantage. Joe, and every other child with autism deserves to be loved, nourished and celebrated for who he is. No autistic child should be denied things that they love for the sake of "normal" appearances. We should never as parents, or a society, expect that the behavior of an autistic child should change, when we are the ones more capable of adaptation. But most of all, we as a generation need to foster the understanding of neurodiversity while freely giving support and acclimation to all who need it. Joe deserves that, as do all of our autistic community.
Learning From Luciana
Tuesday, March 2, 2021
The A Word
Monday, November 9, 2020
Anatomy of experience
Almost six years ago to the date, is when I found out I was pregnant. All moms think they know everything before the baby gets there. It's just the way it is. You say you'll do this, that or the other thing, but you end up buying the Loves diapers and tasting something brown to see if it's chocolate or poop. It happens to all of us. What I'm talking about though, is the assumption that almost all first time moms have, that their children will be perfect.
Somewhere along my journey in motherhood, I read another special needs mom take fault in the old thought that you just care that your baby has ten fingers and toes and looks perfect. That reality isn't so true when you're there in the hospital. Anyone with a child that's had any kind of medical journey can tell you, the only thing that matters is your child surviving, and your survival is second only to that.
The truth is, that birth trauma, complications, and not so "perfect" children is something that just isn't spoken about. Motherhood for me looked nothing like I expected, and for a few years there, was such a lonely existence. Well meaning friends and family assured me that my child was fine. She'd catch up, she'd get there. And yes, it is true, but there was something distressingly wrong with my baby, and no one had the courage to say it, except me.
So why am I up at 11pm writing this on a blog I let die eight months ago along with the beginnings of the COVID crisis? A television show, that honestly I looked at because it had the ever gorgeous David Tennant in, (I could watch him paint walls, truth be told, so the bar is fairly low.) about a family with a daughter (Rosie) who is learning disabled and mostly non-verbal. The very aptly named, "There She Goes".
One episode in and I was sobbing through uncontrollable laughter. They had finally given a voice to these feelings that no one talks about, and most especially emotional process having a child that isn't "perfect" takes parents on.
The first year of Luci's life, I had a myriad of my own problems, but suffice to say her never ending crying, breastfeeding every half hour and never sleeping more than 45 minutes, left me with post-partum psychosis that still can linger at times. Basically I heard her crying at all times, even when she wasn't. I was madly convinced that she was crying, which of course got better with age, but I spent a solid year with that as my reality. I struggled to bond with her, partially because of that, but also partially because the reality was, all she did was cry, and to me, it was me that she didn't like.
Somewhere around a year she turned into a "normal" happy baby. I remember that year in July toting her all over to see friends, and do normal, amazing things. We went on vacation, we visited the beach, it was lovely. That's the first real memory I have of my daughter "liking" me, and I didn't know anyone else in the world felt this way too.
There's a certain grief that I think many people are afraid to discuss, because it's uncomfortable. Who wants to hear someone talk about how they have a child they didn't expect? Shouldn't I be happy my child is alive (I am, trust me, see above)? The grief is there though. It is real, and you can only ignore it for so long before you're sitting on the couch watching David Tennant while you sob your way through a glass of wine.
Parents like this though? They adapt in some really incredible ways, ways I never would have expected for myself six years ago. Things that are so incredibly foreign to the thought of parenting, are somehow normal and mundane. Doctors appointments, therapies, all of that junk? It just becomes so been there, done that, that it is just our lives, and it makes sense to no one but us.
I think that's probably one of the most refreshing, and dare I say healing, of watching this. Both of Rosie's amazing parents are depressed, tired, frustrated, but they shrug it off and just say "fuck it, that's how it is, it sucks, but it's life with Rosie.".
And yeah, that's how it is here.
Today? It was a brilliant Monday. Luci cried until she watched an hour of Pokemon at school lunch time (Which meant yes, she basically melted down for three hours). Andrew was parent MVP today while I took and anxiety pill and hid in bed, waiting for it to kick in. We got it together, bribed her with some fruit snacks, did her school work. This afternoon? I called her ophthalmologist for an appointment, the woman who answered inquired why, and was basically stunned into silence when I said her eyes weren't being symmetrical, but she has cerebral palsy so it could just be her being weird and nothing at all. I know, totally unpolitically correct, but my kid has brain damage, her eyes might just be like that, and I'm not going to disavow knowledge of it. It is what it is.
Our life is complicated, and it's okay. We live in Luci's world, it's insane, messy and completely by her rules. She screams when things don't go the way she thought they would, she hits and pinches because words don't come easy and more times than not she just can't "do" whatever life is asking of her. If any object she gets isn't red? Meltdown. And I don't even know what my kid's weird thing about dogs is. It is what it is, and that is okay.
I think that's one of the most beautiful things about the show though, they did a really eloquent job of showing the dichotomy that was parents interacting with other adults. Friends, family, strangers, and how their mixed myriad of approaches to both Rosie and her parents, impacted them.
It's one of those things I only have the inside view of. I know where I am, but I don't know what it looks like from the outside. Lots of times, we are the loudest in the room with the biggest emotions, and I know that has to be hard to deal with. I know the toll it takes on friends and family to accommodate us at some times, and I know what incredible love we have been given.
When I think about it, it brings me to tears to know that in our lives we've been able to have people around us that treat Luci with such grace, compassion and understanding. It's a fine line, figuring out where the expectations of her are. What point do we push to help her to become acclimated with society, and at what point do we say "eff it"?
Then, a few weeks ago, I had a moment that hit me with such gravity that I have been thinking of it since.
Luci and I drove over to say happy birthday to a friend, and she got to see both the friend and her brother for the first time in person in months and months and months. Socially distanced of course, but Luci was unable to find any words. Her friends? They held space for her, they talked to her, they didn't press her to answer. They understood that she was a person, doing her very best, and in that moment she was worthy of their friendship. My child. My imperfect, complicated little screaming baby, was worthy of friendship.
It's everything a mother ever asks for when you start to hear doctors throwing around diagnosis and outlooks. When it all began years ago, my greatest fear for my daughter was that she wouldn't have anyone besides us that loved her. I cried more nights in bed, playing doctor google, trying to figure out what her future would be like, and if anyone would make that space for her.
She's five. And they did.
At the end of the day, I just feel incredibly grateful to have stumbled on this show. I feel grateful that it helped me cry some tears I have had for probably five of these last six years. It also crystallized some things for me though. Some things I couldn't really figure out until I saw someone else on this journey.
Most of all though, if you've gotten all the way through what is probably a slurry of run on sentences and garbley gook that I'll regret not editing in the morning, know that if you are in our circle, I cherish you so much. I have held myself together as a mother because of those around us. I have held myself together with kind smiles from across the room while I held a screaming child because of you. And I am so damn lucky to have that.
Tuesday, February 25, 2020
Missing the signs
Most first time parents say the same thing, and get more than a handful of surprises when their child comes into the world. But, for special needs parents, it isn't anything at all like that. It could probably be best described as getting a child in a language that no one understands.
It felt like I had been reading all of my prep work for a baby in English, then I was given a child who spoke Mongolian, or Aleut. Sure, I took classes in German and Spanish, and as an adult learned some Japanese, Welsh, Korean, and am conversational in Italian, but I know absolutely nothing about Mongolian or Aleut.
So, I have a baby communicating in a language I don't speak, and I look around me for help. Friends, family, doctors, all of them offering their translation of what my child is saying. All well meaning, intelligent and helpful, but none of them speak the same language as my daughter.
Eventually my daughter does "something" that makes doctors think she can't learn "English" and misses one critical milestone after another. Therapists are called in, they still don't speak her language, but they have seen children like her for years.
Things like that go on for a few years, until finally, I learn the language my daughter speaks. I come to understand her, not the other way around. My understanding of her is the only bridge I can build to connection. I had to go through the process of education and learning, not her.
That's all a big complicated analogy that might only make sense to me, but it's taken me a long time to come to terms with what our journey means. I didn't understand for so long, and am still desperately trying to see the world through my daughter's eyes. I am desperately seeking a journey to understanding her.
Which gets me back to the point of this. Last week I saw a doctor myself to rule out a genetic disorder that both Luciana and I share mild symptoms of. It is as far as we know, the only condition that would outrightly rule out her having Cerebral Palsy caused by Static Encephalopathy, which is a big word for brain damage. Chances are much higher now that our daughter suffered a stroke sometime near her birth.
That's been the hardest part to process for me. It's been four and a half years and I've been unable to confront or reconcile what happened. I've learned in that time that many moms of children with special needs deal with some form of post traumatic stress disorder, and I can certainly understand and imagine I do as well. It took me three and a half years to watch the short clip of my daughter being born, and it was only because we were compiling information for neurology.
I still can't find the words to describe what happened in total. Tears still well in my eyes when I think about the full five minutes it took my daughter to breathe after they pulled her from my arms. The haunting silence of a labor room with a baby that isn't crying is something indescribable. A full ten minutes passed in that silence before she cried out loud and our real journey of parenting started.
Now, four and a half years later, we have a joke around the house about the days, weeks and months that followed. It started with Luciana asking us a few months ago what she was like as a baby. Off handedly one of us answered, "You just cried and cried and cried unless you were getting mama milk". That was entirely the truth of it. We had a baby that screamed, constantly, in Aleut if you will, and nothing seemed to help.
So many people disbelieved us. Doctors said it was any number of things, colic, fourth trimester, indigestion, or just a "normal" baby that wanted to be with her mama. None of them were there when we held a screaming newborn for hours. None of them were in the car when we couldn't go more than a few blocks because her screaming was so incredibly painful to hear in a closed space. None of them were there, laying flat on their backs with a sleeping infant on top of you in bed, because that was the literal only way she was comfortable.
A few years ago I met another mama of a girl who had CP, and the one thing we shared was that we had the most incessantly crying children when they were younger. That, we gathered, was due to some amount of pain they must have been feeling at the time. It made perfect sense to me, their bodies weren't doing what they wanted, all was new, uncomfortable and frustrating.
This week though, with the knowledge that my girl likely had a stroke at some point, I began to look into pain related to strokes, and the flood gates opened.
"Stroke Pain- https://stanfordhealthcare.org/medical-conditions/brain-and-nerves/chronic-pain/types/stroke-pain.html
A stroke keeps blood from reaching the brain and leads to brain tissue damage. About 10% of people who experience a stroke eventually develop severe pain that is called post-stroke pain, central pain, or thalamic pain (after the part of the brain typically affected).
The onset and character of this pain is highly variable. It can arise days or years after the stroke, can arise after a major or a minor stroke, and patients describe the pain they feel in many different ways including (but not limited to) burning, aching, and prickling. Many different body parts can be affected, including the face, arm, leg, trunk or even an entire half of the body.
Common characteristics are that the pain is constant (although there is also often an intermittent stabbing component), and is more likely to occur if the stroke occurred in the right side of the brain. The pain usually gets worse over time and can sometimes be aggravated by temperature changes or movement."
It all came together there. I knew she was in pain, it's just one of those things I've always known, but to know that there is documented pain that occurs after a stroke, and not one doctor thought this was a possibility hurt me to my core. We could have done so much more if they would have sent her for an MRI early on. If the hospital had taken her to the NICU, if we weren't sent home 36 hours after having her. All of it and none of it makes me so upset that no one saw.
So I'm writing this today, in hopes that maybe, just maybe, another new mom reads this, and it helps them. An infant crying for hours upon hours is not normal. Don't take no for an answer. Don't make the same mistakes I did.
Tuesday, February 18, 2020
Awareness
One of the most charged questions I read entirely too often is- “Have you told your child they have X?”
I of course, wondered what the “right” way to do this was. Is there a right way? Is it different for each child? Is there a wrong way?
Our diagnosis’ came late, so maybe it was different for us, but we didn’t have long to ponder this question, if even at all.
A few weeks after her diagnosis of autism, we sat down with Luciana and it went somewhat like this.
“Luciana, do you know what autism is?”
“No.”
“It’s a special way your brain works, and it gave you reading as a super power. Most kids your age aren’t reading like you.”
“Okay.”
“Do you know what cerebral palsy is?”
“No, you say it all the time though.”
“Well, it means when you were born, you were born with a boo boo on your brain, and it’s made it hard for you to do things like walk and run,”
“Does my brain need a bandaid?”
“No, you don’t need a bandaid, and it won’t ever get worse. But we know it might be tougher to do some things than others. But it’s also meant we got to meet some super awesome friends we would have never known. And have gotten to do thing we never would have.”
“Like what?”
“Like dance class, and meeting Miss Addie.”
“Yeah. That’s good.”
Maybe we got lucky, maybe we got out easy, or maybe it distressed her more than we know. It’s hard to tell with a four year old, even a neurotypical one. They don’t have words to describe their feelings, all too often, and have little in the way of past experiences to pull from.
That was almost a year ago.
Recently though, there have been little moments that stand out, that shows me that somewhere in there, she’s learning about the person she is, and how to navigate the world around us.
Today was our second day of swimming lessons. New things are always hard. More times than not, we meltdown half a dozen times before it gets fun. It’s just par for the course. We never push her to do things she doesn’t like, but we don’t let her give up when we know it’s just autism making things hard.
Her meltdown started almost right after walking in the door from school. We mentioned swimming and she started to lose it about how she didn’t want to go. Over and over she said she was scared, she didn’t want to go. I reminded her that she once felt this way about dance class, and school, and how it will pass.
Then she said something I never expected- “I’m just having a shy attack mama. I just need a little time.”
A shy attack. I couldn’t believe how succinctly and poignantly my four year old could sum that up.
So, we gave her time, let her chill out, tried to get her excited and I headed out with her for class.
When we got there, things were alright. We got there early, spent some time getting comfortable, changing, watching others. But, when it came time for her class she went into full meltdown. The kind that I see maybe once a year. It was bad.
Two kind employees came over and tried to do what they could, but sadly she just got more agitated. After a moment, I reminded her of her breathing, got her to sit across from me, and take some deep breaths. Red, blotchy, tear stained face and all.
She looked right at me and said, “I’m having a shy attack.”
I reminded her that it would pass and I never let her do anything that would hurt her.
Then, one of the girls approached her again, and introduced herself. What came from my daughter’s mouth next brought me to absolute tears with pride.
“My name’s Luciana and I have autism. Sometimes it makes me really shy and scared.”
Her conditions are in her records and I’m sure they “know” but lord, I watched the situation take a 180 once those words were spoken. Immediately they switched tracks, made the lesson entirely about her comfort. Took her in the pool room, sat on the bench, let her play with toys, and by the end of it, she was waist deep in the pool.
But the thing I find most powerful is that my daughter had enough self awareness to say, mid meltdown from hell, her best version of “I’m disabled and need extra help please”.
Every parent worries about how the world will treat their child. Every parent of a child who has a disability worries themself sick any number of nights. But once again, my daughter taught me all I needed to know about the subject, and that is, she is strong, she is brave, and she is tenacious. But she also knows how to ask for help, which takes humility and awareness that I didn’t expect from her, but I am so grateful for.
Sunday, February 16, 2020
Choosing to be happy
I thought about that for several days, and what really makes me up as a person. I realized at some point, I simply chose to see things differently. I chose compassion.
Compassion has empowered me to be happy much more than without it. Compassion changed my relationships more than I think I knew, making them much more cherished than they were before. I began to expect the best in others, not defaulting to the worst. That choice unburdened me from anger and resentment I didn’t know I had, and made happiness all the more possible.
I’ve asked myself a million times, why I wasn’t given a “typical” child. I was angry for a long time, both for my daughter and for myself. I was angry that the relationship my daughter and I shared was full of therapies and doctors. That we didn’t spend our time together in play dates and parks, but in clinics.
I was also angry my husband wasn’t going on the same journey. We were on significantly different parenting pages for a long time. He works long hours, and hasn’t been to even a third of the appointments I’ve been to for our daughter. Looking back, it was no surprise he didn’t understand why our daughter could have not only autism but cerebral palsy. His time spent with her was almost all doing “normal” daddy and daughter things.
My relationship with her was spent advocating, assessing, listening to people more knowledgeable than me trying to teach me to do the best for my daughter. I turned into a determined mom, not only to help my daughter every way possible, but also to learn all I could.
Our relationship was completely bound to treatments and therapies. There was no other way around it. At some point though, compassion changed this.
Compassion helped me to understand the tantrums, the difficulties, and the confusion my daughter so often had. It helped me to communicate, to calm and to mediate the problems my daughter was facing. It also helped me to mediate the world around me. Disagreements with my husband became fewer, more engaged, and more focused in resolving than being right. Around me, I began to find happiness in helping others, giving what I could to brighten others lives. The simple act of giving soon began to empower me to a true happiness.
It’s all because of her. It’s all because *I* was chosen by the universe to have this special little girl. I have been entrusted for her, and just as much, I’ve been entrusted in the lives of those around me. It seems overwhelming to put it that way, but the truth of it is, I am capable. I am completely capable of loving instead of hating, of choosing communication over conflict, of assuming the best instead of expecting the worst.
I can, and will, do better for those around me.
Tuesday, February 11, 2020
Coming to terms, with terms.
It started early on, being frightened of simple terms like Autism and Cerebral Palsy. Imagining our future with those words tacked onto us made me so frightened. Eventually, I came to accept that my daughter defined those terms, not the other way around. Autism didn't mean she'd never marry or leave our home and Cerebral Palsy didn't mean she'd never play on a playground. They were just words.
I know this, and I know that words shouldn't bother me, but yet they do.
It started a few weeks ago at a neurology appointment. I injured my back several months ago carrying Luciana. I'm not a strong person, but I'm also not one to complain, but it has come to a point where I can no longer carry her. I asked for a script for a wheelchair for Luciana, so that I could continue to take her places.
Immediately I questioned myself, did my daughter really need one? Our physical therapist seemed to agree, at least in the conversation my husband had with her. She didn't understand why she needed one. And that, made me feel weak and inferior.
But the truth of it is, she's only worked with my daughter for a few months. She isn't there when I have to rub her sore legs, or she can't go on any further without either myself or my husband carrying her. She isn't there when she screams as I put her in or out of a shopping cart, because she's just too big for it, but she doesn't have the stamina to get through a store. No one is, besides us.
Just like our parking placard, I feel so guilty and judged for this. So guilty and judged for needing assistance, and not pushing through. The truth I really need though, was right there all the time.
"Paraparesis", another scary word to read about your child, but it's right there, in black and white on the order for the wheelchair. Partial paralysis of the legs. That is our truth, that is what we live with, and I don't want to discount or disenfranchise the very real struggle that exists, and that we try to overcome every single day.
So in the meantime, I'm reminding myself that a wheelchair will open up the world to us, just like the parking placard did. It will make it possible for me to do more with my daughter. It will mean trips downtown in the summer and walks through the mall. It will mean long meandering days at the arboretum and trips to the pool. It means access for us, and I will not forget that.
Sunday, February 9, 2020
Being the "weird girl"
I was a weird girl, seemingly from infancy. Some of my earliest memories are of my obsession with counting my My Little Ponies, reading Michael Crichton novels in second grade, and mummifying a chicken for my Gifted class. Super cool girl right there. I also remember my atrocious fashion, my inability to play any sports and let's just say I rounded out elementary in super fun, antisocial fashion.
Things sort of got better from there. In high school, I found some other mutants at table nine to hang out with and had a small, but good circle of friends. Its probably because high school is such a rebellious season of life, that we end up finding some acceptance for the things we are, but still, more times than not, I felt like the outsider.
College, well it was still better, but only because I went to a college run by mutants at table nine, and my love of discussing the finer points of Agnes Martin found good company. It was truly one of those magical places that you can't put into words that finds a way of defining you. Among the walls scrawled with glorious graffiti reading "Fuck gouache" and "Roast beef curtains", there was something in that space that allowed a person to thrive, and I still can't put it into words.
What all does this have to do with my daughter?
Thoughts are tangential this way, aren't they? Coming from this, that and the other direction until they make some seemingly obscure sense to our minds.
I was laying in a hot bath today, four in the afternoon. Around me I was listening to a Sofia Coppola soundtrack on vinyl, with a bath bomb claiming to never test on animals and a copy of W magazine a few months old when it hit me. I am still the weird girl, and while I've found some contentment with who I am, how can I be certain she will find it too?
Many of my peers and I are now learning due to any number of factors, that a good portion of "weird girls" actually have autism and were never screened properly for it. Being weird kind of falls into spectrum disorders for females, and it seems like certain things congregate this together for women in the 30-40 age group.
We are learning that our own maladaptive behaviors are actually medically based, and there were any number of reasons for our "weirdness" and for the things that define us. Autism.
So how can I raise a girl, who knows she has autism, and is proud of who she is?
I think back to my time in college, and the environment that allowed that to thrive. It was small, a few hundred in the entire school, and very open concept. We had work to complete, but it was open ended, and allowed for interpretation. We were graded harshly, one famous professor never gave As, because "Ain't nothin' perfect." and TC, lord knows I didn't ever deserve an A from you.
But it had structure in all the right ways, in the ways that pushed you beyond what you thought capable. It was your own self you were pushing against, to find the possibilities within you. Studio doors were always open, seniors didn't mind if freshmen wandered into their studio space at three am to share a beer. It was a beautiful, open collective where the sense of one's self was truly nourished.
I think about that a lot, and in the way I want our daughter to be raised. She's brilliant, but also disabled, and that's a fragile precipice to sit on. Always uncertain and never knowing, but still wanting to trust that intuition that burns so strongly. I get it, because it was me too.
So for now, our home is full of life, full of things that make us happy. We embrace her ideas that fill her with enthusiasm, and nudge her otherwise when she needs it. Our home is full of character, art, music and any number of other weird thing, because we are weird, all three of us, and it is a beautiful and genuine place to be, that so many are never brave enough to find.
-For the record, TC was a great man, and you should read about him.